Time and again, the dispute between the clubs’ lobby organisations flares up behind the scenes. Now the UEC is taking action against UEFA and the European Football Clubs’ Association (EFC) before the European Commission.
Just how much competition does the European football system actually allow? This is a key concern for the Union of European Clubs (UEC) – which has now lodged a complaint with the European Commission against UEFA and the European Football Clubs’ Association (EFC). The complaint targets the Memorandum of Understanding between UEFA and the EFC, which was extended from 2024 to 2033. A central part of the complaint is that UEFA recognises the EFC as the sole representative body for clubs to date and does not permit the EFC to hold dual membership of the UEC. As a result, the concerns of small and medium-sized clubs – particularly those from countries not regarded as top footballing nations in Europe – are given little consideration.
Criticism: Group of clubs exerts central influence over UEFA
The UEC, which FC St. Pauli recently joined as the first (and so far only) German club, sees itself as their representative body. Prominent members of the UEC, which represents just under 140 clubs, have also joined, including FC Burnley, CA Osasuna and Royale Union Saint-Gilloise. The EFC comprises more than 900 clubs. However, voting and speaking rights are distributed on a tiered basis, which is another point of criticism raised by the UEC against its UEFA partner.
This cooperation, it is claimed, grants a select group of clubs decisive influence over participation in European competitions and the distribution of revenue. This, it is argued, contravenes EU competition law. The complaint is based on Articles 101 and 102 of the TFEU, which prohibit cartels, and seeks a formal investigation, the publication of the current agreement and the removal of the anti-competitive clauses. One point of criticism is that 16 club officials would hold dual roles within the EFC and the UEFA Club Competitions Committee. The latter, in fact, exerts a dominant influence on the structure and revenue distribution of the Champions League, Europa League and Conference League.
Study finds 80 per cent of places in the top-tier competitions held by just 50 clubs
According to a study commissioned by the UEC itself, 80 per cent of places in the Champions League have been occupied by just 50 clubs since 2000. Of the 4.4 billion euros in revenue from the current rights cycle, clubs not represented in European competitions receive just seven per cent in solidarity payments; this does, however, represent an increase of three per cent compared with the previous rights period. However, this will do little to alter the competition-stifling influence of the Champions League’s billions, both in UEFA tournaments and in the national leagues.
Most recently, for example, the association presented a model – the Player Development Reward – designed primarily to strengthen youth-developing clubs. “This alone would have seen around 67 million euros flow to clubs outside the top flights in the 2025/26 season. Nevertheless, these clubs are being denied a seat at the negotiating table where decisions about their future are being made,” criticises UEC President Ovidiu Costesin, who is also managing director of Romanian champions Universitatea Craiova: “We fully respect UEFA’s role. But respect must not be synonymous with silence. Every club deserves a voice.”
Former FIFA Governance Chief Maduro as Legal Adviser
This Tuesday, UEC representatives will submit their complaint in Brussels, which is based on the ECJ ruling on the Super League and the dominant market position of UEFA recognised therein. Interestingly, the legal advice was provided by Prof. Miguel Maduro, a lawyer well known in the world of sport. The former Advocate General at the ECJ was once also chairman of FIFA’s Governance and Audit Committee, but – like the German ethics judge Hans-Joachim Eckert later on – was dismissed by the world governing body amid considerable protest. Most recently, the Portuguese lawyer criticised the awards of the 2030 and 2034 World Cups as lacking transparency and anti-competitive; he also questioned whether Gianni Infantino is eligible for election at the next FIFA Congress in accordance with the statutes.

